Revlon Lip Butters, as they are both moisturising with amazing pigmentation. The packaging is really nice and sleek, I like that the handle part is clear it is different to anything else I have. The colour I picked up is 03 Lovely Rose, a gorgeous baby pink colour which is very build able and creamy and extremely wearable. I personally did find this more mositurising than the Revlon Lip Butters I own, but the consistancy of Lovely Rose feels more waxy when you apply it than soft and balmy, so I think these would last better in the heat than the Revlon Lip Butters. The Rouge Caresse's have the same perfumed scent as the other L'oreal lipsticks but with this lip colour once applied you can't smell it really.
Over all I really like this lip balm/lipstick and think it is different enough to the lip butters to justify owning many of both ;) I have my eye on Daring Coral which looks like a very wearable coral who can say no to that?! Does anyone own any of the L'oreal Rouge Caresse's?